Home

FicMachine vs AI Dungeon: Writing a Story vs Playing an Adventure

·5 min read

TLDR: AI Dungeon is a text adventure game. You play a character, take actions, and the AI narrates what happens next. FicMachine is a story you write with the AI. It looks and feels like a book. You can edit the text easily, and the AI continues the story exactly where it left off, even mid-sentence. If you want to play, using the AI as the dungeon master, AI Dungeon is the better platform. If you want to write, using the AI as a cowriter, try FicMachine. It's free with unlimited generations, and Premium is $5/month.

Features

FicMachineAI Dungeon
Free planYesYes
Unlimited generations on the free planYes (3 models)Yes (9 models)
Memory on the free plan2,000 tokens4,000 tokens
Cheapest paid plan$5/month$14.99/month
Memory on the cheapest paid plan8,000 tokens8,000 tokens
Largest memory available8,000 tokens128,000 tokens
Image generationNoYes
Community scenariosYesYes
Multi-month discountsNoYes

AI Dungeon details from their memberships page, checked November 2026.

How it feels

In AI Dungeon you take turns. When you play, you pick an action type (Do/Say/Story) and the AI narrates what happens next. That loop is great when you want to play: you have a character, goals, and a world that reacts to you.

FicMachine has no turns, chat bubbles or action boxes. Your story is one continuous page of text. You write a paragraph, or half a sentence, and press Continue, and the AI picks up where you stopped. Each continuation is short (about 150 words), so you stay in control: keep what you like, rewrite what you don't, and steer the story by writing the first few words of what should happen next.

In AI Dungeon you are a player and the AI is the dungeon master. In FicMachine you are the author and the AI is your co-writer.

Memory

Every AI story tool has a limit on how much of your story the AI can "see". Past that limit, it starts forgetting the beginning.

  • On the free plans, AI Dungeon remembers more: 4,000 tokens vs FicMachine's 2,000 (about 1,500 words).
  • At the entry paid tier, both offer 8,000 tokens (about 6,000 words). FicMachine charges $5/month for it, and AI Dungeon's Journey tier charges $14.99.
  • If you want more than 8,000 tokens, AI Dungeon is the right choice. Its Legend ($29.99) and Mythic ($49.99) tiers go up to 16k and 32k. The shadow tiers go even further. FicMachine doesn't offer more than 8k today.

On both AI Dungeon and FicMachine you can Inspect the Context at any time to see exactly what's in the AI memory.

Where AI Dungeon is better

  • It feels like a game. If you want to play a character and have the world react to you, AI Dungeon is built for that.
  • More memory on the free plan and on the higher tiers.
  • Image generation included through Credits.
  • A bigger, older community with a much larger catalog of adventures.

Where FicMachine is better

  • It feels like a novel. If you want to be creative, edit the story easily, and read it like a book.
  • Price. 8,000 tokens of memory for $5/month instead of $14.99.
  • Simple. There's only one button.

Which one should you pick?

  • Pick AI Dungeon if you don't like the AI writing for your character, you want an adventure game, image generation, or more than 8k tokens of memory and you're happy to pay $30–50/month for it.
  • Pick FicMachine if you liked writing in AI Dungeon more than playing it, and you wished it were easier to do.

You can try FicMachine without signing up: start a story or browse community scenarios.

FAQ

Is FicMachine a good AI Dungeon alternative? If what you enjoyed was writing/directing the story, yes. FicMachine drops the action/turn structure and lets you co-write continuous prose. If you enjoyed playing a character in a game world, AI Dungeon does that better.

Is FicMachine free? Yes. Generations are unlimited on three models, and the premium models have 20 continue actions per day each. The Premium subscription ($5/month) gives the AI 4x more memory and unlimited actions for all the models.

Can I edit anything that AI writes? Yes. On FicMachine editing the story is easier because it's just a continuous page of text. Click anywhere and change it, or use Rephrase, Retry and Undo.

Does FicMachine moderate stories? Only stories and scenarios you publish to the community are moderated. Private ones are for your eyes only and are not moderated.

Which AI models does FicMachine use? Lunaris, Mistral Nemo, Muse, DeepSeek 3.2, Gemma 4, MiMo 2.6 Flash and Hemmingway. See the models page.